Relias Media - Continuing Medical Education Publishing

The trusted source for

healthcare information and

CONTINUING EDUCATION.

  • Sign In
  • Sign Out
  • MyAHC
    • Home
      • Home
      • Newsletters
      • Blogs
      • Archives
      • CME/CE Map
      • Shop
    • Emergency
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Hospital
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Clinical
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • All Access
      • Subscribe Now
      • My Subscription
    • My Account
      • My Subscriptions
      • My Content
      • My Orders
      • My CME/CE
      • My Transcript
    Home » Consent refused? Take appropriate action

    Consent refused? Take appropriate action

    August 1, 2013
    No Comments
    Reprints
    Facebook Twitter Linkedin Share Share

    Related Articles

    For success with frequent ED utilizers, take steps to understand patient needs, connect them with appropriate resources

    Providers must take action to get patient compliance

    Take immediate action when violations occur

    Consent refused? Take appropriate action

    The courts are most likely to side with the doctor

    (Editor's Note: This is a two-part series on legal risks involving parents refusing medical care for a child. This month, we cover reporting obligations for physicians in this scenario. Last month, we covered what to document to reduce risks.)

    In 2002, a police officer took custody of a 5-week-old febrile infant girl after her parents refused to consent to a spinal tap to rule out meningitis.

    "The physicians were concerned that failure to timely diagnose and treat meningitis could lead to death or permanent brain injury. Additionally, published guidelines recommend a spinal tap in this situation," says Jonathan M. Fanaroff, MD, JD, associate professor of pediatrics at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine and co-director of the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at Rainbow Babies & Children's Hospital, both in Cleveland, OH.

    The parents sued the police department, hospital, and physician, and alleged a violation of their constitutional rights. A federal jury rejected the parent's claims and found in favor of the police, hospital, and physicians.1

    Parents are the primary decision-makers when it comes to medical treatment for their children, and this is the basis for the requirement to obtain parental informed consent, says Fanaroff. "Parents have an obligation, however, to provide needed medical care for their children," he says. "Additionally society has an interest in protecting children from harm. This is known as the doctrine of parens patriae."

    When a parent's refusal to consent to treatment is life-threatening for the child or places the child at risk of serious harm, then the physician has a legal duty to report the situation to the appropriate child protection agency or law enforcement. "Child protection agencies, as well as the court system, are both empowered to take emergency custody of the child and provide consent for medical treatment," says Fanaroff.

    Though Congress passed the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) in 1974, the federal government has deferred to states to define abuse/neglect, notes John W. Miller II, principal at Sterling Risk Advisors, Marietta, GA. The CAPTA amendments of 1996 and 2003 contained no federal requirement for a parent to provide any medical treatment for a child if that treatment is against the parent's religious beliefs. "However, CAPTA also designates that there is no requirement that a state either find, or be prohibited from finding, abuse or neglect in cases where parents or legal guardians act in accordance with their religious beliefs," says Miller.

    In almost every state, physicians are mandatory reporters and are legally required to report suspected child abuse or neglect when presented with reasonable cause, says Miller.

    "An [against medical advice] discharge or elopement can rise to the level of neglect depending upon your state's definition," adds Miller. "Be familiar with your state's definitions of neglect. Be aware of your obligations to report such activity to the proper authorities." (The U.S. Department of Health & Human Services' Child Welfare Information Gateway provides searchable by state definitions of child abuse and neglect, along with definitions for who are mandatory reporters in each state and what duties they have to report suspected abuse. Go to http://1.usa.gov/LsWxGs.)

    Reference

    1. Mueller v. Auker, 576 F. 3d 979-Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit 2009.

    SOURCES

    • Jonathan M. Fanaroff, MD, JD, Associate Professor of Pediatrics, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, OH. Phone: (216) 844-3387. Fax: (216) 844-3380. Email: jmf20@case.edu.
    • John W. Miller II, Principal, Sterling Risk Advisors, Marietta, GA. Phone: (678) 424-6503. Fax: (678) 424-6523. Email: jmiller@sterlingriskadvisors.com.

    Post a comment to this article

    Report Abusive Comment

    Physician Risk Management

    View PDF
    Physician Risk Management 2013-08-01
    August 1, 2013

    Table Of Contents

    A growing number of lawsuits involve poor communication — multiple MDs involved

    MD got dismissed due to this documentation

    Suit alleged failure to follow up on result

    Radiology misreads are tough to defend

    When a radiology finding is missed, make case defensible

    Patient can't hear you? Legal risks abound

    Residents make more errors when they work shorter shifts

    Will med/mal suit be filed? Here's how attorneys decide

    Consent refused? Take appropriate action

    Physician Legal Review & Commentary: 16-year-old male awarded $450,000 for failure to diagnose appendicitis 6 days later, primary care doctor finds infection

    Physician Legal Review & Commentary: Case involved controversial procedure: manipulation under anesthesia

    Shop Now: Search Products

    • Subscription Publications
    • Books & Study Guides
    • Webinars
    • Group & Site
      Licenses
    • State CME/CE
      Requirements

    Webinars And Events

    View All Events
    • Home
      • Home
      • Newsletters
      • Blogs
      • Archives
      • CME/CE Map
      • Shop
    • Emergency
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Hospital
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Clinical
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • All Access
      • Subscribe Now
      • My Subscription
    • My Account
      • My Subscriptions
      • My Content
      • My Orders
      • My CME/CE
      • My Transcript
    • Help
    • Search
    • About Us
    • Sign In
    • Register
    Relias Media - Continuing Medical Education Publishing

    The trusted source for

    healthcare information and

    CONTINUING EDUCATION.

    Customer Service

    customerservice@reliasmedia.com

    U.S. and Canada: 1-800-688-2421

    International +1-404-262-5476

    Accounts Receivable

    1-800-370-9210
    ReliasMedia_AR@reliasmedia.com

    Mailing Address

    • 1010 Sync St., Suite 100
      Morrisville, NC 27560-5468
      USA

    © 2021 Relias. All rights reserved.

    Do Not Sell My Personal Information  Privacy Policy  Terms of Use  Contact Us  Reprints  Group Sales

    For DSR inquiries or complaints, please reach out to Wes Vaux, Data Privacy Officer, DPO@relias.com

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing