Relias Media - Continuing Medical Education Publishing

The trusted source for

healthcare information and

CONTINUING EDUCATION.

  • Sign In
  • Sign Out
  • MyAHC
    • Home
      • Home
      • Newsletters
      • Blogs
      • Archives
      • CME/CE Map
      • Shop
    • Emergency
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Hospital
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Clinical
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • All Access
      • Subscribe Now
      • My Subscription
    • My Account
      • My Subscriptions
      • My Content
      • My Orders
      • My CME/CE
      • My Transcript
    Home » Blogs » Compliance Mentor » Wheaton College Wins Fight Against ACA’s Contraceptive Mandate

    Compliance Mentor
    Compliance Mentor RSS FeedRSS

    compliance-mentor-static-reliasmedia

    Free Monthly News from the Award Winning Publisher of:

    • Hospital Access Management
    • Hospital Case Management
    • Hospital Employee Health
    • Hospital Infection Control
    • Hospital Peer Review
    • Healthcare Risk Management
    • Case Management Advisor
    • IRB Advisor
    • Medical Ethics Advisor
    • Same-Day Surgery

     

    Wheaton College Wins Fight Against ACA’s Contraceptive Mandate

    March 22, 2018
    No Comments
    Reprints
    Facebook Twitter Linkedin Share Share
    By Robert B. Vogel, MD, JD

    Robert B. Vogel, MD, JD
    Retinal Ophthalmologist at Piedmont Eye Center, Lynchburg VA;
    Attorney, Overbey Hawkins & Wright, PLLS, Lynchburg, VA;
    Adjunct Professor, Humanities and Bioethics, Liberty University School of Medicine, Lynchburg, VA.

    The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (NDI) has issued a permanent injunction preventing the federal government from enforcing on Wheaton College, a Chicago-area Christian liberal arts school, the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) contraceptive mandate. The injunction follows a four-year legal fight.

    Wheaton argued that its being required to provide contraceptive coverage to employees violated its sincerely held religious beliefs. This claim was based on the U.S. Constitution and the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA).

    The RFRA, enacted in 1993, mandates that the highest level of judicial scrutiny – “strict scrutiny” – be applied when evaluating whether a neutral law of general applicability violates the First Amendment’s free exercise of religion clause.

    In other words, a law may not impose a “substantial burden” on religious freedom unless it furthers a “compelling government interest” and is the “least restrictive means” to achieve that interest. Although the Supreme Court eventually held the RFRA unconstitutional as applied to the states, it still applies to federal laws.

    Wheaton’s injunction request initially was denied by the NDI and the Seventh Circuit. Both cited Notre Dame v. Sebelius (2014), where the circuit court found that Notre Dame failed to show the ACA mandate would impose a “substantial burden.”

    But in 2014 Wheaton appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted a temporary injunction but did not decide the case on its RFRA merits. The case moved back to the DNI but was put on hold pending resolution of Zubik v. Burwell, decided in 2016.

    In Zubik, the Supreme Court combined seven cases brought by plaintiffs similar to Wheaton. The Supreme Court remanded those cases to lower courts so that both sides in the disputes could “arrive at an approach” that “accommodates [religious employers’] religious exercise” and the ACA’s contraceptive coverage mandate.

    Another development working in Wheaton’s favor came in October 2017, when the Trump Administration broadened Obama-era exemptions to the contraceptive mandate. More important for Wheaton, the administration agreed in this case “that enforcement [of the contraceptive mandate]…would violate RFRA.”

    That is, the government told the court that it “did not oppose Wheaton’s renewed motion for injunctive and declaratory relief.” The court ruled in Wheaton’s favor.

    But controversy regarding the contraceptive mandate is not going away soon.

    Federal courts in California and Pennsylvania have issued preliminary injunctions against the Trump administration rules cited above. Both courts stated that given the change in the government’s position regarding these rules, opportunity for notice and comment was required under the Administrative Procedure Act. 

     

    Post a comment to this article

    Report Abusive Comment

    www.reliasmedia.com

    Compliance Mentor

    View PDF
    Compliance Mentor - March 2018
    March 1, 2018

    Table Of Contents

    DC Court Rules on Limits on Medicaid DSH Payments

    Pennsylvania Hospital and Cardiology Group Will Pay Millions to Settle FCA Allegations

    Wheaton College Wins Fight Against ACA’s Contraceptive Mandate

    Tennessee Nursing Home Pays to Resolve FCA Claims of Substandard and Worthless Care

    Shop Now: Search Products

    • Subscription Publications
    • Books & Study Guides
    • Webinars
    • Group & Site
      Licenses
    • State CME/CE
      Requirements

    Webinars And Events

    View All Events
    • Home
      • Home
      • Newsletters
      • Blogs
      • Archives
      • CME/CE Map
      • Shop
    • Emergency
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Hospital
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • Clinical
      • All Products
      • Publications
      • Study Guides
      • Webinars
      • Group Sales
    • All Access
      • Subscribe Now
      • My Subscription
    • My Account
      • My Subscriptions
      • My Content
      • My Orders
      • My CME/CE
      • My Transcript
    • Help
    • Search
    • About Us
    • Sign In
    • Register
    Relias Media - Continuing Medical Education Publishing

    The trusted source for

    healthcare information and

    CONTINUING EDUCATION.

    Customer Service

    customerservice@reliasmedia.com

    U.S. and Canada: 1-800-688-2421

    International +1-404-262-5476

    Accounts Receivable

    1-800-370-9210
    ReliasMedia_AR@reliasmedia.com

    Mailing Address

    • 1010 Sync St., Suite 100
      Morrisville, NC 27560-5468
      USA

    © 2021 Relias. All rights reserved.

    Do Not Sell My Personal Information  Privacy Policy  Terms of Use  Contact Us  Reprints  Group Sales

    For DSR inquiries or complaints, please reach out to Wes Vaux, Data Privacy Officer, DPO@relias.com

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing