In physician profile data, home-grown is best
In physician profile data, home-grown is best
When you launch a physician profiling project within your medical office, remember there's a world of difference between a warehouse full of data and a couple of useful measures reflecting the daily effectiveness of the practice. "Data about your own practice is the best starting point for improving it," explains practice management consultant Susan Bellile, president of Westchester, IL-based Q3 Inc. "Besides, if you bring the doctors actual data, it's immediate. It generates more excitement than trying to get them to support something that won't produce figures for six or 12 months."
You can turn to these two sources for numbers on which to build profiles:
1. Hospital data.
Bellile suggests asking your inpatient facility's quality improvement director to lend a hand in obtaining statistics on the physicians in your office. Be aware, however, that some hospitals only release such data to the physicians. So you might need an authorization from one of your doctors.
On the other hand, you might discover that the hospital routinely sends the very information you need and it's just lying on somebody's desk. "Until the doctors get interested in these types of reports, they'll go unread," Bellile observes.
Advantages.
· Most institutions compile reports by DRG categories, comparing physicians by costs and lengths of stays. "Hospitals usually have all the details behind the reports," Bellile says, "like breakdowns by DRG and on lab and drug costs."
· Hospital databases often compare each data set to corresponding numbers from the state or geographic region. They also compare each doctor to hospital and statewide norms.
· Hospital quality improvement programs have an incentive to cooperate with your profiling project, she adds, "after all, if a doctor has high inpatient costs, it's a negative reflection on the hospital."
· As your group compares the treatment costs among the different hospitals they use, obvious cost discrepancies might provoke fruitful discussions.
Limitations.
· Hospitals usually lack accurate and uniform methods of charging pieces of care episodes to the doctor who actually rendered the care. For example, an emergency department (ED) physician admits a patient suffering chest pains. Does the record assign the open heart surgery to that same ED doctor or to the cardiovascular surgeon from your practice who performed the bypass? The point is to find out how cases are assigned to each doctor so you can determine which charges in an episode of care actually belong to the physicians in your office.
· Different hospitals present their data differently, so if your doctors practice at various institutions, you'll need to arrange reports in a consistent fashion before you can use them.
2. Claims data.
These statistics are probably easiest to come by because payers send them regularly. They often determine the size of physician bonuses from respective payers.
Advantages.
· The data will give you a snapshot of your practice from the insurers' perspective. "It's there and you might as well use it," Bellile says. "Other people are looking at it so you should know what they're seeing."
Limitations.
· Claims data are less detailed than hospital data. So if certain charges are abnormally high, you won't see the severity adjustments for comorbidities or complications which help distinguish justified expense from overutilization.
· Claims data only reflect the portion of your patient population covered by that plan.
In spite of hospital and claims data limitations, Bellile says, they're still a great starting point from which to create your own tools. She adds, "Physician groups will ultimately develop the most comprehensive profiles because they have the overview of what happens to patients across the continuum." (See cover story for more details on the challenges and answers to the task of engaging physicians in changing their care practices.)
[For further information on physician profiling methods, contact:
· Susan Bellile, Q3 Inc., One Westbrook Corporate Center, Suite 300, Westchester, IL 60154. Telephone: (708) 236-1727. Fax: (708) 236-1728.
· Other resources for developing physician profiles are available through medical specialty associations as well as the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 104 Inverness Terrace East, Englewood, CO 80112-5306. Telephone: (303) 799-1111. World Wide Web: http://www.mgma.com. MGMA is offering a free report, Quality Management in the Medical Group Practice: Lessons on Measuring, Benchmarking and Improving Performance (Item #4988). To order call (888) 608-5602 or (303) 397-7888.]
Subscribe Now for Access
You have reached your article limit for the month. We hope you found our articles both enjoyable and insightful. For information on new subscriptions, product trials, alternative billing arrangements or group and site discounts please call 800-688-2421. We look forward to having you as a long-term member of the Relias Media community.